Sierra Club

Having trouble receiving our e-mail? Try adding us ( to your Address Book.
View a web version of this email.

Sierra Club
Explore, Enjoy and Protect the Planet
RAW: Uncooked Truth, Beyond Belief 

Issue #274
Nov 21, 2008
Greens to Blame for Detroit's Red Ink?

Undaunted by electoral and economic collapse, conservatives continue to sing from the same disastrous songbook they've been using for decades. In response to the imminent failure of the American auto industry a conservative chorus has struck up one of their favorite old standards: it's fuel economy standards that are killing Detroit.

(This comes after round one earlier this week when Detroit's woes were blamed on another famed conservative bogeyman -- organized labor.) 

The bridge trolls at the Wall Street Journal editorial page began the fun this week, dashing off a nice little missive called "The Environmental Motor Company: Making Detroit a Subsidiary of the Sierra Club."  The piece called on Congress to lift the "onerous fleet-mileage standards (CAFE rules) that force the companies to make cars domestically that are unprofitable." Huh? Then for good measure it took a swipe at the California global warming emissions standards for cars before hitting its crescendo: "[Congressional Democrats] want an entirely different American auto industry that serves goals other than selling cars to consumers." Well, duh.

(The idea of the Sierra Club running Detroit reminds me of a line Obama used toward the end of the campaign in his stump speech. It was a story about Obama asking a dyed in the wool Republican to vote for him and give Democrats a chance to run the economy after eight years of the Bush administration's failed policies. "Couldn't do any worse," a grinning Obama would say to raucous laughter.)

Like so many lemmings marching toward a cliff, other conservatives then took to the airwaves to peddle the CAFE lie.  Mitt Romney: "There's no question but that the CAFE standards have put an unusual burden on the domestic automobile manufacturers." Bill Kristol: "Well, one problem with the auto industry is we have been telling them how to operate an awful lot, you know, in terms of CAFE standards and other things…" Sean Hannity: "They [the government] -- you know, between the unions, between trade policy, safety standards, CAFE standards, you know, economy, fuel economy standards, they're forcing these auto companies to be in a position where they're not as competitive."

Luckily, Speaker Pelosi is standing strong and refusing to strip out the conditions for the $25 billion in retooling loans already available to the automakers. And in terms of another $25 billion bailout (which the Sierra Club supports with the right conditions attached), just yesterday she said "until they show us the plan [for viability], we cannot show them the money." 

We're all for recycling at the Sierra Club, but it's time for conservatives to spring for some new talking points when it comes to the auto industry's woes.



RAW is the Sierra Club's weekly e-mail update in which our team of Sierra Club correspondents bring you humorous insights about environmental stories you won't want to believe.

Subscribe to RAW.

Unsubscribe from RAW.

Tell a Friend about RAW.

View previous editions of RAW.

Become a Sierra Club Member.

Want to keep up with the Sierra Club's latest activities and news?
Sign up to receive Sierra Club Insider, the Sierra Club's flagship e-newsletter sent out twice a month. The Insider provides everything from information on new reports and issues to planning great hiking trips to how you can help change environmental policy. View recent editions of the Insider.

Sierra Club | 85 Second St., San Francisco, CA 94105 | |

Update My Profile | Manage My Email Preferences | Update My Interests